Skip to main content

Resource Libraries

Braces With Pulled Teeth vs Expanders: Which Is Safer?

Why palatal expansion beats extraction orthodontics for breathing, what the science shows on airway health, and how Dr. Felix Liao links the jaw to oxygen.

Dr. Teresa Scott
Braces With Pulled Teeth vs Expanders: Which Is Safer?

Airway Health in Oral & Holistic Health Approaches: What the SCIENCE shows

Our members now have access to several exclusive airway webinars taught by Dr. Felix Liao, founder of Holistic Mouth Solutions. Airway is far too big of a topic to cover in a single Facebook post, which is why these trainings exist, but this post will give you a strong foundation to understand why airway is the missing link in both oral health and whole-body wellness.

AIRWAY HEALTH & SYSTEMIC WELL-BEING

Airway is life. If you don’t breathe, you don’t live. You cannot sleep, swallow, digest, think clearly, regulate emotions, or heal without adequate oxygen. A healthy airway affects everything: oxygen delivery, sleep quality, cardiovascular stability, metabolic health, emotional resilience, child development, immune function, and longevity. Dr. Liao explains this through one of the most accurate metaphors I’ve ever heard:

A Six-Foot Tiger in a Three-Foot Cage

The Tiger is your tongue and your body’s enormous oxygen demand. The Cage is your airway and your dental arches, the bony framework you breathe through. If the cage is too small, the tiger suffers. And when the tiger suffers, the entire body pays the price. Chronic airway insufficiency contributes to or worsens:

  • sleep apnea and snoring

  • chronic fatigue

  • high blood pressure

  • high blood sugar

  • headaches and migraines

  • anxiety and depression

  • metabolic syndrome and insulin resistance

  • thyroid disruption

  • TMJ issues and facial pain

  • ADHD-like symptoms in children

  • behavioral issues

  • grinding, clenching, and bruxism

  • asthma-like symptoms

  • obesity

  • bedwetting

  • mouth breathing

  • forward head posture

  • chronic inflammation

Few patients ever connect these symptoms to their mouth: but they should.

WHY OUR “CAGES” GOT TOO SMALL

Humans are designed to have:

  • room for 32 teeth (32 bars on their cage)

  • a tongue that fits comfortably in the mouth

  • naturally wide dental arches

  • nasal-predominant breathing

But over the last 2 centuries, our jaws have steadily gotten smaller. The research points back to one primary cause:  Generational Nutritional Injury. Modern diets, especially for infants and toddlers, are overly soft and processed. Soft diets require almost no chewing, which leads to:

  • weak chewing muscles

  • underdeveloped jaws

  • narrow palates

  • reduced nasal airway

  • poor tongue posture

  • chronic mouth breathing

When children don’t chew, their jaws don’t grow. When jaws don’t grow, the tongue loses room. And when the tongue loses room, the airway collapses. If you want to understand how this happened, look into the work of Dr. Weston Price and Dr. Francis Pottenger. You will never look at commercial baby food, pouches, purées, or early feeding practices the same way again. Babies were meant to chew, not slurp their way into airway restriction.

HOW ORTHODONTICS ACCIDENTALLY MADE EVERYTHING WORSE

Around the 1950s, orthodontics became an official specialty. By that point, dentists had already spent a century noticing that people’s teeth were becoming increasingly crowded, but instead of asking why, orthodontists turned to the simplest aesthetic fix: pull the teeth that don’t fit. My own dad had his bicuspids pulled for this reason. He was born in 1937. By 1963, almost 50% of children receiving orthodontic treatment had four bicuspids removed. Even today, extraction rates hover around 20%: and I will say it out loud:  At least 99% of modern bicuspid extractions were preventable with early airway-focused expansion. Extraction-based orthodontics MUTILATED the airway health of four consecutive generations. It is not an exaggeration to call it both a tragedy and a travesty.  

NOW, I don't want you to go shooting the orthodontists.  In all fairness, they didn't know any better than the dentists who have been putting mercury and fluoride in people's mouths for the last 150 years.  They just didn't know.  It was ignorance.  And not even willful ignorance.  The body of evidence is now growing, so more and more orthodontists are becoming airway centered.  But it wasn't there even 25 years ago.  It's just going to take time. Like every other medical and dental advancement.  Airway-centered orthodontists are the equivalent of biological dentists in the orthodontic world.  They are rare and precious and at the leading, cutting-edge of what they are doing.  

THE FALSE PROMISE OF “MAKING ROOM”

Orthodontists sold bicuspid extraction as a way to “make room.” Let me explain why that logic collapses. If you have 32 bars in a cage and you remove four or 8 of them (bicuspids and wisdom teeth), rearranging the remaining bars so they look straight and pretty… Did the cage get any larger? NOPE. Extraction does not:

  • enlarge the jaw

  • widen the palate

  • increase airway volume

  • create room for the tongue

  • improve nasal airflow

  • improve breathing

It simply removes bars and redistributes the rest. Aesthetically? It looks pretty. For awhile. Until the gums start to recede from the resulting traumatic bite relationship. Functionally? AN UNMITIGATED DISASTER. I cannot tell you how many patients I see destroying their teeth, joints, and sleep because their airways never had a chance.

“BUT THE STUDIES SAY EXTRACTION DOESN’T SHRINK THE AIRWAY…”

Yes, several studies conclude exactly that:

And they’re technically correct. But only because the studies asked the wrong question. They are BAD SCIENCE. These researchers looked at adults after their bicuspids had already been removed and asked: “Did the airway get smaller after extraction?”

But they did not ask the only question that matters:

“What would this airway have looked like if the palate had been EXPANDED instead of EXTRACTED?”

They did not measure:

  • airway potential

  • nasal airflow resistance

  • oxygen saturation

  • sleep quality

  • Epworth Sleepiness Scale

  • metabolic markers

  • hypertension risk

  • thyroid function

  • TMJ loading

  • posture

  • clenching and grinding

  • behavior in children

  • quality of life

They studied static adult airways after the developmental damage was irreversible. So yes, extraction “didn’t shrink the airway.” Because the airway was already too small to begin with.
The tragedy is what the airway could have been if expansion had been used. This is why I don’t mince words here:  What was done to those children was FUNCTIONAL MUTILATION of the airway and tongue space that altered their entire physiology.

And the consequences echo for a lifetime.

THE RESEARCH FINALLY CAUGHT UP: WHAT EXPANSION REALLY DOES

What Happens When We Expand the Cage Instead of Removing Bars?

When you stop asking, “Does extraction make the airway smaller?” and instead ask:

“What happens if we EXPAND the jaws in growing children?”

…the literature looks very different.

Across multiple studies and reviews, non-surgical rapid palatal/maxillary expansion (RPE/RME) in children has been shown to:

  • increase nasal airway dimensions

  • reduce nasal resistance and obstruction symptoms

  • improve sleep quality and apnea–hypopnea index (AHI)

  • improve oxygen saturation

  • improve behavior, fatigue, and parent-reported quality of life

A few key examples:

  • Yoon et al., 2021 (Sleep & Breathing) – Impact of rapid palatal expansion on the internal nasal valve and obstructive nasal symptoms in children
    Kids with nasal obstruction who underwent RPE showed significant widening of the internal nasal valve and reduced obstructive nasal symptoms, i.e., they could actually breathe through their noses better. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32648185/

  • Galeotti et al., 2023 – Effects of rapid palatal expansion on the upper airway in children with SDB
    RPE in children with sleep-disordered breathing increased upper airway dimensions on cephs and was associated with improvement in clinical symptoms. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36832373/

  • Inchingolo et al., 2025 (J Clin Med) – Assessment of the Effect of RME on Nasal Breathing and OSAS in Children
    A 2025 clinical study found that RME enhanced nasal breathing and reduced OSAS severity in children with maxillary constriction and sleep-disordered breathing. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41010785/

  • Ashok et al., 2014 – Effect of RME on sleep characteristics in normal children
    Even in children without diagnosed SDB, RME improved sleep quality parameters on polysomnography, suggesting that expansion supports healthier sleep and breathing even before “disease” is obvious. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25395765/

  • Helal et al., 2019 (Open Dentistry Journal) – Parent-reported outcomes after RME
    Parents reported better breathing, reduced snoring, improved sleep and less fatigue after their children underwent RME; 3D evaluation in a subset showed increased nasal cavity volume. https://opendentistryjournal.com/VOLUME/13/PAGE/85/FULLTEXT/

  • Children with syndromes / special populations:
    RME has even improved nasal patency and breathing in children with Down syndrome and maxillary constriction, a population notoriously hard to treat for airway issues. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16008071/

And more recently:

  • Aksilp et al., 2025 (Sleep & Breathing) – RCT comparing RME vs adenotonsillectomy in pediatric OSA
    RME showed comparable improvements in AHI and some sleep metrics to adenotonsillectomy, although AT still did better on symptom scores and QoL – but the key point: skeletal expansion holds its own as a legitimate airway treatment, not just a cosmetic orthodontic add-on. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12310760/

Only in the last 10–15 years have CBCT studies finally measured what happens when we widen the cage. And the research is remarkably consistent:

Expansion improves airway: significantly, reliably, and across all ages.

Here is the integrated science:

Account required

Sign in to see more

Create an account or sign in to unlock the full list.